| Name | Score | Price | City |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Eager Beaver | 9.2 | $13.50 | Niagara Falls |
| Pete's Pizza | 9.2 | $16.95 | Niagara Falls |
| Pie Guys Pizzaria | 9.1 | $17.46 | Niagara Falls |
| Yank's Old Niagara Bar & Grill | 9.1 | $18.24 | Niagara Falls |
| Franks Pizzaria | 9 | $17.29 | Niagara Falls |
| Pizzaria | 8.9 | $18.65 | Niagara Falls |
| Carmine's Pizzeria | 8.9 | $17.52 | Niagara Falls |
| Zappi's | 8.9 | $15.76 | Niagara Falls |
| Antica Pizzaria | 8.8 | $18.07 | Niagara Falls |
| Sal's Pizzeria | 8.6 | $16.95 | Niagara Falls |
| Johnny Roccos Pizza Wagon | 8.6 | $10.00 | Niagara Falls |
| The Brick Oven Pizza Company | 8.5 | $13.00 | Niagara Falls |
| Johnny Roccos | 8.4 | $17.80 | Niagara Falls |
| Napoli Ristorante Pizzeria | 8.4 | $23.73 | Niagara Falls |
| Metro Bakery | 8.4 | $19.00 | Niagara Falls |
| Queen's Guard Pub | 8.3 | $17.25 | Niagara Falls |
| Carson's Pizzaria | 8.2 | $17.50 | Niagara Falls |
| Dairy Queen | 8.2 | $11.49 | Niagara Falls |
| Gino's Pizza | 8.1 | $11.29 | Niagara Falls |
| Eighty 88 Eight South | 8.1 | $19.21 | Niagara Falls |
| Boston Pizza | 7.9 | $26.73 | Niagara Falls |
| La Farina Bakery | 7.9 | $16.00 | Niagara Falls |
| YNot Again | 7.8 | $17.90 | Niagara Falls |
| Camp Cataract | 7.8 | $17.28 | Niagara Falls |
| Pasta Fresca | 7.8 | $15.80 | Niagara Falls |
| Your Neighbourhood Pizza Co | 7.8 | $13.50 | Niagara Falls |
| Portage Bakery | 7.7 | $18.00 | Niagara Falls |
| Riverside Tavern | 7.6 | $16.95 | Niagara Falls |
| Mick & Angelos | 7.5 | $20.34 | Niagara Falls |
| Hooligans Sports Bar | 7.4 | $17.00 | Niagara Falls |
| Qualia Pizza | 7.3 | $11.30 | Niagara Falls |
| D'Vinci's | 7.3 | $15.53 | Niagara Falls |
| Italia Pizzeria | 7.3 | $11.29 | Niagara Falls |
| Spicy Olive Bar and Grille | 7.2 | $19.20 | Niagara Falls |
| Costco Wholesale Canada | 7.2 | $14.68 | Niagara Falls |
| Chip N Charlies | 7.1 | $19.21 | Niagara Falls |
| Red Swan Pizza | 7.1 | $12.35 | Niagara Falls |
| Little Caesars Fanceroni Pizza | 7.1 | $19.20 | Niagara Falls |
| Carpaccio Restaurant | 6.9 | $18.08 | Niagara Falls |
| Clancy's Restaurant and Bar | 6.9 | $19.25 | Niagara Falls |
| Your Neighbourhood Pizza Co | 6.8 | $13.00 | Niagara Falls |
| Casa D'Pizza | 6.8 | $19.77 | Niagara Falls |
| City South Pizza | 6.6 | $12.42 | Niagara Falls |
| Cat's Kitchen + Bar | 6.4 | $15.81 | Niagara Falls |
| Wingz N Thingz Pizza | 6.2 | $15.81 | Niagara Falls |
| Pete's Pizza | 6.2 | $11.30 | Niagara Falls |
| Gamblers | 6.1 | $14.70 | Niagara Falls |
| My Cousin Vinny's | 6.1 | $23.30 | Niagara Falls |
| Dominoes | 6.1 | $11.29 | Niagara Falls |
| Twice The Deal | 5.9 | $7.90 | Niagara Falls |
| Noor's Subs and Pizza | 5.8 | $12.00 | Niagara Falls |
| Mama Mia's Italian Etery | 5.7 | $15.24 | Niagara Falls |
| Blind Pig Niagara | 5.7 | $17.24 | Niagara Falls |
| Pizza Pizza | 5.2 | $10.16 | Niagara Falls |
| Pizza Party All Night | 5.2 | $13.83 | Niagara Falls |
| PZA MIA | 4.9 | $12.42 | Niagara Falls |
| Little Caesars | 4.7 | $14.68 | Niagara Falls |
| Papa Johns | 4.4 | $24.30 | Niagara Falls |
| Strada West | 4.4 | $20.34 | Niagara Falls |
| Commisso's | 3.9 | $24.85 | Niagara Falls |
| Jumbo's | 3.6 | $11.50 | Niagara Falls |
| Everyday Pizza | 2.1 | $11.00 | Niagara Falls |
| Il Sorriso Cafe & Pizzeria | 0 | $0.00 | Niagara Falls |
| RT Pizza | 0 | $0.00 | Niagara Falls |